Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts

Saturday, December 22

Things I read on the plane (part II)

"[W]hat is worst of all is to advocate Christianity, not because it is true, but because it might be beneficial...To justify Christianity because it provides a foundation of morality, in stead of showing the necessity of Christian morality from the truth of Christianity, is a very dangerous inversion."

T.S. Eliot, The Idea of Christian Society

Tuesday, November 20

Morality and the Law III

The last couple posts have present some other folks' view on morality and the law. I've been thinking about the following from "Christianity and the (Modest) Rule of Law:"

"If we weren’t so closely linked with the campaign to prohibit gambling, evangelicals might speak with more authority — moral, not legal — when criticizing, say, state governments’ all-out efforts to promote their own lotteries."

Is this distinction between moral and legal authority valid? If so, I wonder if American evangelicals bolster their legal authority in the political arena at the expense of the moral authority they believe (or should believe) they already possess. The general assumption is that "legal moralism" comes from the strong moral views of Christians, but I am afraid it really comes from the Church's fear that its moral authority has become irrelevant.

I am uneasy about covering up a position of fear and weakness with a facade of dogmatism and power--particularly where the Church is concerned. It conjures images of the insecure playground bully who is really just in need of a friend.

Even if the Church's moral position (rightly) leaks over into the legal realm, I would assume that the Church's moral authority is much stronger than its legal authority. It appears that many evangelicals mistakenly see politics and the law as a way to make Christianity culturally relevant in a post-modern society through brute force. If one truly believes that only Jesus can meet our spiritual needs, the Christian faith is already relevant in society--post modern or not--assuming that society always carries a Jesus-sized spiritual void. Regular Joes off the street are likely to think we are more sure about our policy solutions than our religious conviction; when the term "evangelical Christian" has become more associated with a particular political party than a man called Jesus, I have the feeling something is wrong.

Saturday, November 17

"The Relationship Between God's Law and Man's" or "Morality and the Law II"

In "Christianity and the (Modest) Rule of Law," Bill Stuntz and David Skeel argue that Christian morality should lead to a breed of moral libertarianism rather than moral legalism.

"One might reasonably expect professing Christians to be especially attuned to the dangers of legal moralism. Judging from contemporary culture-wars debates, we aren’t. The heart of the problem is a tendency to confuse God’s law with man’s. Those of us who believe in a divine moral law are regularly tempted to try to write that law into our much less-than-divine code books....

Why do evangelical Christians find it so hard to resist the attractions of legal moralism?... Starting in the 1940s, evangelical leaders, many of them connected to Christianity Today, the principal voice of conservative evangelicalism, began calling for a renewed commitment on the part of believers to engage and influence the culture around them. 'From Carl Henry and Harold Ockenga in the 1940s,' as Christian Smith puts it, 'to Francis Schaeffer and Mark Hatfield in the 1960s and 1970s, to Charles Colson and Anthony Campolo in the 1980s and 1990s, evangelicals have been driven by a vision of redemptive world transformation." If the end is to transform a law-saturated culture like contemporary America’s, legal reform seems a natural means. Debates over legal limits on abortion, gambling, and Enron-style corporate immorality become tools for healing a spiritually diseased society....But the cure risks worsening the disease....

In short, legal moralism is nearly always counterproductive. In Christian terms, it is also deeply wrong. Jesus’s definitions of adultery and murder proved that immorality and illegality cannot and must not be coextensive. God’s law reigns over a broad empire that man’s law cannot hope to govern. Good moral principles are often vague and open-ended, and they reach into every nook and cranny of our lives and our thoughts. Legal principles that have these qualities only serve to invite arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement. Arbitrariness and discrimination in turn invite contempt for the law....

Conflating God’s law and man’s law thus does violence to both. It makes far too much of man’s law, and far too little of God’s."

Tuesday, November 13

Morality and the Law

In a recent talk, Kim Forde-Mazrui had three suggestions for those who seek to create laws based on moral grounds. He was talking specifically about gay marriage and adoption, so the examples were drawn from that perspective. The suggestions themselves, however, may be more broadly applied.


  1. Weigh moral benefits against moral harms: For example, the moral benefit of prohibiting gay adoption arguably results in the moral harm of having parentless foster children and orphans.

  2. Consider that you are mistaken: Slavery, anti-miscegenation, segregation, etc. were all supported on moral grounds at various points in American history.

  3. Consider compromise: Consider distinguishing between civil and religious marriage.
I can see where he's coming from. I do not believe that all of Christendom hangs on having American law perfectly mirror God's law. To what extent is it beneficial or necessary to have man's law reflect Christian morality? The typical assumption in the Evangelical community is that the closer US laws are to the Bible the better. I am not sure that is true for a few reasons:
  1. God ultimately seeks changed hearts, not changed laws. Has the American Church flipped this around? (See Americans are incurable legal optimists....American Christians...have been more American than Christian).

  2. If it's so important for national laws to match up with the Law, why didn't Jesus focus on fixing the laws of the Roman government.

I'm not saying that law is not important. I think that laws can be redeemed too (see the previous post). Maybe it's just a matter of priority.

Tuesday, October 30

Do The Right Thing

Yesterday I read an article about Gap Inc.’s response to its most recent child labor allegations. According to the report, the responsible vendor in India was working 10 year-old children for 16 hour days without pay in a workplace where the toilets flooded the hallways. If the children cried, they were either hit with a rubber pipe, or punished with an oily cloth stuffed in their mouths.

The Gap President responded by announcing that the responsible subcontractor was fired, affirming the company’s refusal to use child labor, and stating that he personally felt “violated,” “very upset,” and “angry.”

I recount the details of this story not because they are necessarily new allegations for the Gap, not because I am suggesting a boycott on Gap clothing (I wear a lot of solid-colors), and not even because I think these facts are all that shocking for anyone who pays a little attention to world affairs. What I find more interesting is the company’s response- to do the “right” thing. And I was thinking that the Gap got lucky on this ethical dilemma: the “right” thing turned out to be the popular thing.

No normal member of our society would support a system like the one described above. I would like to assume that if child labor was widely accepted by American clothing-buyers that the Gap would still refuse to use it, but the public response to these types of allegations certainly make the decision easier. And there are many other “right” things that our culture honors on both individual and corporate levels: donating to charity, volunteering in a community project, dialoging about ways to end racism, researching environmentally-friendly products and services. Even on the more debatable hot-button issues (abortion or homosexual rights), there seem to be organized groups on both sides of the issues that would support anyone who did the “right” thing in their eyes.

Does this mean that it is easier to do the right thing today than it used to be? Does it mean that there are just as many right-but-unpopular decisions that are overlooked by our society? Is it harder to be the Atticus Finch today than 100 years ago? Is it even possible for someone today to make a decision that makes them stand almost completely alone from their contemporaries?
Perhaps we have made it easier for people to choose the right, at least on some level, and perhaps this is good. I wonder, though, whether we have lulled ourselves out of the need to cultivate this kind of courage.

Sunday, October 14

Can ethical negotiators be effective negotiators?


Here's a passage from The Intelligent Negotiator:

When the car dealer begins the initial discussions by saying "I cannot go below the $22,500 sticker price, " and the prospective purchaser begins by saying "I will not go above the $19,000 dealer cost," have they engaged in reprehensible dishonesty? Most people who consider this issue carefully are likely to answer "no." A truthful individual is not a person who always tells the truth, but a person who tells the truth when the truth is expected. Most of us would not consider it dishonest to compliment a colleague's new outfit or hairstyle though we do not find it attractive, or to falsely tell an acquaintance we have another engagement when asked to attend a dinner we would prefer to avoid. We recognize that a truthful response would be considered needessly cruel.

Do you buy his assertion that lying is context based? Proverbs says "The LORD detests lying lips, but he delights in men who are truthful. (Prov. 12:22). But does a false statement that doesn't deceive constitute a lie?

It seems that in certain circumstances when you are negotiating with another party who might not expect puffery/embellishment, false statements are likely to deceive. God comes out pretty strongly against injustice, and in my mind, taking advantage of someone at the negotiating table, whether by lying or not, should be avoided.

What about in the case of two experienced negotiators who expect the other person to use false statements? That seems to remove the problem of deception, so we're left with wondering whether a false statement on its own is morally wrong. "The righteous hate what is false" (Prov 13:5a). This comes as no surprise since Jesus describes himself as the Truth (John 14:6). However, assuming that puffery is a necessary element of effective negotiating, it's hard to believe that Christians are called to avoid it entirely.